my mind on books

Lots of enticing new reviews at Metapsychology Online Reviews this week, including these:

• Things and Places: How the Mind Connects with the World by Zenon W. Pylyshyn
• Mind in Life: Biology, Phenomenology, and the Sciences of Mind by Evan Thompson
• Consciousness and Mental Life by Daniel N. Robinson
• The Concept ‘Horse’ Paradox and Wittgensteinian Conceptual Investigations by Kelly Dean Jolley

Better Than Conscious?: Decision Making, the Human Mind, and Implications For Institutions (Strüngmann Forum Reports) ed. by Christoph Engel and Wolf Singer (MIT Press, 2008)

From the product description:

Conscious control enables human decision makers to override routines, to exercise willpower, to find innovative solutions, to learn by instruction, to decide collectively, and to justify their choices. These and many more advantages, however, come at a price: the ability to process information consciously is severely limited and conscious decision makers are liable to hundreds of biases. Measured against the norms of rational choice theory, conscious decision makers perform poorly. But if people forgo conscious control, in appropriate tasks, they perform surprisingly better: they handle vast amounts of information; they update prior information; they find appropriate solutions to ill-defined problems.

This inaugural Strüngmann Forum Report explores the human ability to make decisions, consciously as well as without conscious control. It explores decision-making strategies, including deliberate and intuitive; explicit and implicit; processing information serially and in parallel, with a general-purpose apparatus, or with task-specific neural subsystems. The analysis is at four levels–neural, psychological, evolutionary, and institutional–and the discussion is extended to the definition of social problems and the design of better institutional interventions. The results presented differ greatly from what could be expected under standard rational choice theory and deviate even more from the alternate behavioral view of institutions. New challenges emerge (for example, the issue of free will) and some purported social problems almost disappear if one adopts a more adequate model of human decision making.

Preprint of the Max Planck Institute for Research on Collective Goods (22 p. pdf by Engel and Singer)

Ernst Strüngmann Forum information

These are books on consciousness published in 2008, selected from WorldCat, which means they are in some library’s collection:
The Achilles of Rationalist Psychology (Studies in the History of Philosophy of Mind) ed. by Thomas M. Lennon and Robert J. Stainton (Springer, 2008)

In his Second Paralogism of the Critique of Pure Reason, Kant described what he called the “Achilles of all dialectical inferences in the pure doctrine of the soul.” This argument, which he took to be powerful yet fatally flawed, purports to establish the simplicity of the human mind, or soul, on the basis of the unity of consciousness. In Kants illustration, the unity had by our perception of a verse cannot be accounted for if the words of the verse are distributed among parts thought to compose the mind. The argument, or at least the unity of consciousness that underpins it, has a history extending from Plato to the present. Moreover, many philosophers have extended the argument, some of them using to argue such views as immortality.

It is the aim of this volume to treat the major figures who have advanced the argument, or who have held views importantly bearing on it. Original essays by scholars with expertise on the relevant authors treat Plato, Aristotle, the Neoplatonists, the medievals, Descartes, Locke, Cudworth, Bayle, Clarke, Spinoza, Leibniz. Hume, Mendelsohn, Kant, Lotze, James, as well as those working in contemporary cognitive science on what is called the binding problem of how the human brain can unify the elements of experience into a single representation.

Consciousness Transitions: Phylogenetic, Ontogenetic and Physiological Aspects ed. by Hans Liljenström and Peter Århem (Elsevier Science, 2008)

It was not long ago when the consciousness was not considered a problem for science. However, this has now changed and the problem of consciousness is considered the greatest challenge to science. In the last decade, a great number of books and articles have been published in the field, but very few have focused on the how consciousness evolves and develops, and what characterizes the transitions between different conscious states, in animals and humans. This book addresses these questions. Renowned researchers from different fields of science (including neurobiology, evolutionary biology, ethology, cognitive science, computational neuroscience and philosophy) contribute with their results and theories in this book, making it a unique collection of the state-of-the-art of this young field of consciousness studies.

Developmental Perspectives on Embodiment and Consciousness (Jean Piaget Symposia Series) ed. by Willis F. Overton, Ulrich Müller, and Judith L. Newman (Lawrence Erlbaum, 2008)

This latest volume in the Jean Piaget Society Symposia Series illustrates different ways in which the concept of embodiment can be used in developmental psychology and related disciplines. It explores the role of the body in the development of meaning, consciousness, and psychological functioning. The overall goal is to demonstrate how the concept of embodiment can deepen our understanding of developmental psychology by suggesting new possibilities of integrating biological, psychological, and socio-cultural approaches….

MindReal: How the Mind Creates its Own Virtual Reality by Robert Ornstein (Malor Books, 2008)

This is a book that shows, in simple detail, one of the most startling findings of modern science: We don’t experience the world as it is, but as virtual reality. And while much of the latest scientific work demonstrates this, as do many of the classical psychological illusions, it is an important meeting point for students of the mind, brain, philosophy and religion because, as we can now see in light of this book, all these disciplines begin at the same place.

This is not an abstruse treatise, but part graphic novel and part direct address. It allows the reader a breakthrough understanding of the mind which is not available anywhere else. It is, in part, a summa of Dr. Ornstein’s research and writing of the past 35 years (with pieces and references to many of his works) as well as a seminal introduction to new readers.

The Reflexive Nature of Consciousness (Advances in Consciousness Research) by Greg Janzen (John Benjamins Publishing Co., 2008)

Combining phenomenological insights from Brentano and Sartre, but also drawing on recent work on consciousness by analytic philosophers, this book defends the view that conscious states are reflexive, and necessarily so, i.e., that they have a built-in, “implicit” awareness of their own occurrence, such that the subject of a conscious state has an immediate, non-objectual acquaintance with it. As part of this investigation, the book also explores the relationship between reflexivity and the phenomenal, or “what-it-is-like,” dimension of conscious experience, defending the innovative thesis that phenomenal character is constituted by the implicit self-awareness built into every conscious state. This account stands in marked contrast to most influential extant theories of phenomenal character, including qualia theories, according to which phenomenal character is a matter of having phenomenal sensations, and representationalism, according to which phenomenal character is constituted by representational content.

Ontology of Consciousness: Percipient Action (MIT Press) spent a long time as a “forthcoming” book but has finally made its own crucial ontological shift to “published.”

To me, the title doesn’t convey that the book is looking at consciousness from a wide range of disciplinary and cultural perspectives, which I think is needed to throw into perspective the assumptions made by one’s own culture and discipline.

Here is the product description:

The “hard problem” of today’s consciousness studies is subjective experience: understanding why some brain processing is accompanied by an experienced inner life. Recent scientific advances offer insights for understanding the physiological and chemical phenomenology of consciousness. But by leaving aside the internal experiential nature of consciousness in favor of mapping neural activity, such science leaves many questions unanswered. In Ontology of Consciousness, scholars from a range of disciplines–from neurophysiology to parapsychology, from mathematics to anthropology and indigenous non-Western modes of thought–go beyond these limits of current neuroscience research to explore insights offered by other intellectual approaches to consciousness.

These scholars focus their attention on such philosophical approaches to consciousness as Tibetan Tantric Buddhism, North American Indian insights, pre-Columbian Mesoamerican civilization, and the Byzantine Empire. Some draw on artifacts and ethnographic data to make their point. Others translate cultural concepts of consciousness into modern scientific language using models and mathematical mappings. Many consider individual experiences of sentience and existence, as seen in African communalism, Hindi psychology, Zen Buddhism, Indian vibhuti phenomena, existentialism, philosophical realism, and modern psychiatry. Some reveal current views and conundrums in neurobiology to comprehend sentient intellection.

MIT Press’s site includes the Table of Contents plus full text of the Foreword by Robert Thurman, the Preface by Helmut Wautischer, and the Introduction by Stanley Krippner.

Thanks to Eric Schwitzgebel for posting about his Tucson presentation.

Also, having found the “search” function at National Review Online, I was able to pull up all of John Derbyshire’s excellent reports:

“Academic Theater” (Thursday 4/10)

“Panprotoexperientialism, Anyone?” (Thursday 4/10)

“Conscious of the Border” (Friday 4/11)

“End of Consciousness” (Sunday 4/13)

[update 4/15: The John Derbyshire Consciousness Collection has all the above posts plus a couple more.]

[update 4/18: Pete Mandik’s blog has links to his presentation on Consciousness Without Subjectivity; also thanks for the links to David Chalmers’s photos (and don’t miss the party pics!)]

[more 4/28: Anand Rangarajan posted a review of the conference (found via David Chalmers’s blog)]

Here’s a link to the earlier post that collected some reports from the beginning of the conference.

By the way, some of the earlier Tucson conferences were turned into books!:
Toward a Science of Consciousness III: The Third Tucson Discussions and Debates (Complex Adaptive Systems)
Toward a Science of Consciousness II: The Second Tucson Discussions and Debates (Complex Adaptive Systems)
Toward a Science of Consciousness: The First Tucson Discussions and Debates (Complex Adaptive Systems)